I thought I would let you know, all 3 of my beers turned out. Im not overly impressed with any of them, but people seemed to like them. I think "free" helped people appreciate it more.
I brewed 3 box beers from Fryar Tucks:
The Weisenbeer was the first beer. It has somewhat of a tin taste in it. Its drinkable and I will drink it but its not great... I would give it a 2 out of 10. Just slightly better than bud. My friend who is much more experienced said there is no off flavor and though it just needs to age a bit. It has improved over a couple weeks, but its still not very good.
The Oktoberfest was the second beer. It was the most popular. This was the only brew that came with a specialty grain and I think I steeped it too hot. It has the taste like if you steep tea too hot. Despite that, its still drinkable. I give this a 3.5 out of 10. Much better than bud but I wouldnt try to recreate it.
The American Cream Ale was the third and final beer. This one was my favorite and turned out pretty well. I just dont like it that much. I cant say there is anything "wrong" with it, it just seems like its missing something. I would give it a 4 out of 10. Again, I wouldnt try to recreate this one.
Thanks to Czar and Bevoduz for the bottles. I hope to give them a good home and keep them full of beer when possible. I would offer you both samples, but honestly, they arent good. I would rather hold off a bit, get a little more skill, and give you something that turns out better. If you think you want to try them anyway, let me know, I can bring some by.
Again, thank you both, I really appreciate your generosity.